Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

C&TS Comm. Has NO EXPERIENCE to estab. FRA ng spec

PRSL
December 11, 2002 09:24AM
The Cumbres & Toltec Scenic RR Commission should not establish narrow gauge track standards for the FRA or nation’s narrow gauge railroads.
Presently there are no FRA track standards for any narrow gauge railroad and therefore any FRA inspector is “out of jurisdiction” if he measures any gauge or count any ties. The C&TS does not have the experienced career people who can make a fair list of standards, which will not make narrow gauge railroad far more expensive to maintain than any standard gauge line. It took decades and hundred of railroads impute to develop the Standard Gauge specification and years of public hearing and corrections.
Will narrow gauge track require tie plates? I am sure the C&TS folks who are to draw up these specifications do not know what is the allowed plate cut depth into a tie to reach the limits of a failed tie. It took years of review to decide what is acceptable for safety and that has never been done on the C&TS. Maybe the White Pass & Yukon would have more qualified people to say how they want the track that they operate over. But will the East Broad Top want to comply with that kind of track, and have to put tie plates on every tie? How about all the other ng tourist lines that are under FRA interest?
There is no safety need for any Federal intrusion into any narrow gauge railroad in this ENTIRE NATION! The TRAINS Organization should get this stopped on the C&TS Commission and get the FRA to reconsider the request as the FRA only have authority to operate “in need of safety” and there is no deaths or injuries to justify such a government expansion of control.
Subject Author Posted

Report On The Commission Meeting 12-09-02

roger hogan December 10, 2002 10:06AM

Re: Report On The Commission Meeting 12-09-02

Frank Martindell December 11, 2002 08:37AM

Re: Next time you are in Chama

Jay Wimer December 12, 2002 06:03AM

C&TS Comm. Has NO EXPERIENCE to estab. FRA ng spec

PRSL December 11, 2002 09:24AM

C&TS specific written standards

Mark Valerius December 11, 2002 10:35AM

Re: C&TS Comm. Has NO EXPERIENCE to estab. FRA ng

Paul D December 11, 2002 10:41AM

Re: Why not use D&RGW practice as standard? *NM*

Brian Barr December 11, 2002 12:07PM

Common Sense

Bob Keller December 11, 2002 03:42PM

Re: Much ado about nothing

Jay Wimer December 11, 2002 05:32PM

Re: C&TS Comm. Has NO EXPERIENCE to estab. FRA ng

Robby Peartree December 11, 2002 06:21PM

Re: C&TS Comm. Has NO EXPERIENCE to estab. FRA ng

PRSL December 11, 2002 07:04PM

Re: C&TS Comm. Has NO EXPERIENCE to estab. FRA ng

E December 11, 2002 08:00PM

Re: C&TS Comm. Has NO EXPERIENCE to estab. FRA ng

Gavin Hamilton December 12, 2002 02:54AM

The CTSRR and the FRA *PIC*

Jay Wimer December 12, 2002 05:29AM

what the heck,over...

jorge gigante December 12, 2002 09:32PM

Re: C&TS Comm. Has NO EXPERIENCE to estab. FRA ng

Linn W. Moedinger December 12, 2002 05:41AM

more like Fox in the Hen house

Rodger Polley December 13, 2002 10:31PM

Written stds aren't a bad thing

Steven Haworth December 12, 2002 08:46AM

Re: Written stds aren't a bad thing

Mik December 12, 2002 02:03PM

No argument there...

Steven Haworth December 12, 2002 02:11PM

Re: No argument there...

Mik December 12, 2002 09:03PM

Re: No argument there...

DvV December 13, 2002 05:08AM

The C&TS must have and use Trk. Specifications.

PRSL December 14, 2002 09:50AM

Re: The C&TS must have and use Trk. Specifications *PIC*

Greg Scholl December 14, 2002 11:41AM

Yes, and it will Endanger all NG lines,except WP&Y *NM*

PRSL December 14, 2002 04:36PM

Being adversarial to the FRA is a dead end street.

Kelly December 15, 2002 07:26AM

Why does this discussion of track get into boilers

PRSL December 15, 2002 09:14AM

Why does this discussion of track get into boilers

Kelly December 15, 2002 10:43AM

Re: Being adversarial to the FRA is a dead end str

G. W. Laepple December 15, 2002 10:25AM

Re: The C&TS must have and use Trk. Specifications

Robby Peartree December 15, 2002 08:30AM

Re: The C&TS must have and use Trk. Specifications

Earl Knoob December 15, 2002 12:54PM

Above Post Make my Case, but are off Que

PRSL December 15, 2002 03:56PM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.