Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Then again, probably not . . .

John Craft
June 12, 2001 07:12AM
I remember hearing about some differences between Chinese and American locomotives when J. David Conrad was there to oversee the building of the 3 (later 4, after 141 went in the drink) "American" Chinese engines. My memory may be faulty, but I think the biggest indigestion was over staybolt spacing - Chinese practice apparently is a safety factor of less than the American requirement of 4.
That same philosophy - a safety factor of 3 or 3.5, let's say, instead of 4.0 - would also come to play in boiler plate thickness, bracing, material spec, etc. I simply don't remember how it was addressed - stronger material could restore a safety factor of 4.0, but the resulting design might have still required a waiver from ASME, NBBPVI, and/or FRA.
Other things - metric vs. Imperial threads, measurements, etc. - caused headaches, but no real safety concerns.
There have also been reports that some parts imported for use here, like injectors, were a bit less reliable than the American originals.
JAC
Subject Author Posted

Locomotive Construction

Bob Keller June 11, 2001 06:52PM

Re: Locomotive Construction

Fred T June 11, 2001 09:29PM

Then again, probably not . . .

John Craft June 12, 2001 07:12AM

Re: Then again, probably not . . .

Fred T June 12, 2001 08:37AM

Re: Then again, probably not . . .

Tom Shreve June 12, 2001 09:30AM

Chinese boilermaking. . .

Steve Zuiderveen June 12, 2001 06:21PM

Re: Chinese boilermaking. . .

Mik June 12, 2001 11:03PM

Re: Locomotive Construction

Dan Markoff June 11, 2001 10:42PM

Re: Locomotive Construction

Curtis F. June 12, 2001 01:13PM

Glenbrook boiler

Dan Markoff June 12, 2001 06:30PM

Re: Glenbrook boiler

Curtis F. June 12, 2001 09:58PM

Re: Locomotive Construction

Curtis F. June 12, 2001 01:26PM

Re: Locomotive Construction

Bob Keller June 13, 2001 08:00AM

Now you'r talking, Bob!

Glen Brewer June 12, 2001 04:41PM

Promontory replicas

C Hawkins June 12, 2001 05:16PM

Re: Promontory replicas

Mudhen June 13, 2001 07:49AM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.