December 04, 2020 08:25AM
|
|
Registered: 16 years ago
Posts: 679
|
Full disclosure up front.. I crew, maintain, and shovel coal into D&RGW 315. I'm also on the BOD of the DRHS. Oh and I rebuild and paint rolling stock. I am very biased to coal!!
I have read ALL the comments on the discussion of Coal vs Oil for our steam engines.... And after all the discussion it seems that the only alternative to using coal is the oil fired option...
I present yet a third option.... I think that there is enough engineers in the world of steam and outside of railroading that a modern solution of an add on scrubber of some sort, to prevent live cinders from leaving the stack, could be developed if we put enough brainpower and outside of the box thinking and engineering behind it.
Yes I'm aware of the "Bear Trap" device the D&S and others have tried, and the "water Mist injectors" and others..... it's a good start, but I think that those attempts were given up on way before completion of the end goal. Gave up to soon before final solution was achieved.
Smoke box technology has evolved from day one of steam engines. "Short Boxes", "Long Boxes", Deflectors, Master Mechanics, Cyclone and such... Diamond stacks, Onion Stacks, Short and Tall strait stacks. It appears that the evolution time has come around again. We have access to some very brilliant engineers in the world, that just love to solve hard complex problems... Look at Space X... Young brilliant engineers, said " Don't tell us we can't fly a first stage rocket booster back to a soft landing so we can reuse it, Get out of our way and we will show you how its done!!!" And they did and it's completely changed space launches forever.... Keeping burnings cinders from leaving a smoke stack, just has to be easier then sending a electric Tesla red roadster to Mars..
Jumping down off my soap box after using up my $.02 worth.
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 12/04/2020 08:29AM by dave2-8-0.
Subject |
Author |
Posted |
|
Tenderpaw |
November 26, 2020 09:20PM |
|
Will Gant |
November 26, 2020 09:58PM |
|
alcofan |
November 27, 2020 09:34AM |
|
Chris Webster |
November 27, 2020 10:51AM |
|
kcsivils |
November 27, 2020 10:58AM |
|
Dougwood1954 |
November 28, 2020 01:50AM |
|
dapenguin |
November 29, 2020 03:08AM |
|
AZ Railfan |
November 27, 2020 03:08PM |
|
bcp |
November 27, 2020 03:48PM |
|
Will Gant |
November 27, 2020 05:18PM |
|
bcp |
November 27, 2020 05:50PM |
|
drgw0579 |
November 27, 2020 07:08AM |
|
nickgully |
November 27, 2020 07:36AM |
|
MD Ramsey |
November 27, 2020 03:08PM |
|
Will Gant |
November 27, 2020 05:20PM |
|
Russo Loco |
November 27, 2020 07:11PM |
|
michael |
November 27, 2020 08:35AM |
|
Greg Scholl |
November 27, 2020 12:13PM |
|
Joe Weigman |
November 27, 2020 11:55AM |
|
12bridge |
November 27, 2020 01:16PM |
|
usmc1401 |
November 27, 2020 01:43PM |
|
Ron Keagle |
November 27, 2020 03:12PM |
|
Ron Keagle |
November 29, 2020 08:18AM |
|
Kevin Cook |
November 29, 2020 11:33AM |
|
Josh McNeal |
November 30, 2020 12:10PM |
|
Will Gant |
November 30, 2020 01:14PM |
|
Scott Gibbs |
November 30, 2020 04:01PM |
|
Will Gant |
November 30, 2020 07:39PM |
|
michael |
November 27, 2020 05:57PM |
|
declergn |
November 27, 2020 05:57PM |
|
Chiloquinruss |
November 27, 2020 07:14PM |
|
Tom Smith |
November 28, 2020 10:57AM |
|
Jimr260 |
November 28, 2020 03:43PM |
|
redrob |
November 28, 2020 04:37PM |
|
Hoss |
November 28, 2020 04:38PM |
|
Kelly Anderson |
November 28, 2020 11:54AM |
|
Tenderpaw |
November 28, 2020 12:39PM |
|
Samart |
November 28, 2020 01:00PM |
|
kcsivils |
November 28, 2020 04:11PM |
|
Tenderpaw |
November 28, 2020 05:40PM |
|
redrob |
November 28, 2020 06:23PM |
|
Kelly Anderson |
November 28, 2020 07:11PM |
|
Josh McNeal |
November 30, 2020 12:18PM |
|
Hoss |
November 28, 2020 04:45PM |
|
RichB |
November 29, 2020 07:10AM |
|
Samart |
November 29, 2020 07:16AM |
|
Greg Scholl |
November 29, 2020 08:50AM |
|
Steve Forney |
November 29, 2020 01:21PM |
|
Earl |
November 28, 2020 09:16PM |
|
Joe Weigman |
November 29, 2020 11:30AM |
|
drgw0579 |
November 30, 2020 05:45PM |
|
Chris Walker |
November 30, 2020 07:54PM |
|
michael |
November 30, 2020 05:51PM |
|
michael |
November 30, 2020 05:54PM |
|
Mark Valerius |
December 01, 2020 12:19PM |
|
Greg Scholl |
December 01, 2020 02:01PM |
|
Will Gant |
December 01, 2020 02:33PM |
|
Russo Loco |
December 01, 2020 08:42PM |
|
JoeK |
December 01, 2020 09:29PM |
|
Will Gant |
December 01, 2020 09:57PM |
|
Samart |
December 02, 2020 07:52AM |
|
redrob |
December 02, 2020 08:38AM |
|
JoeK |
December 02, 2020 07:23PM |
|
Greg Scholl |
December 02, 2020 07:25AM |
|
Samart |
December 02, 2020 07:53AM |
|
alcofan |
December 02, 2020 08:45AM |
|
Greg Scholl |
December 02, 2020 08:53AM |
|
Glenn Butcher |
December 02, 2020 08:53AM |
|
heatermason |
December 02, 2020 01:16PM |
|
Ed Horan |
December 02, 2020 02:58PM |
|
Jimr260 |
December 02, 2020 04:27PM |
|
heatermason |
December 02, 2020 06:06PM |
|
T A Hunter |
December 02, 2020 09:42AM |
|
Greg Scholl |
December 02, 2020 10:11AM |
|
BrockD&RGW488 |
December 02, 2020 11:14AM |
|
bcp |
December 02, 2020 11:19AM |
|
BrockD&RGW488 |
December 02, 2020 11:21AM |
|
Kelly Anderson |
December 02, 2020 11:57AM |
|
JoeK |
December 02, 2020 07:44PM |
|
Johnson Barr |
December 02, 2020 01:18PM |
|
JoeK |
December 02, 2020 08:07PM |
|
Johnson Barr |
December 03, 2020 12:05PM |
|
hank |
December 03, 2020 06:02PM |
|
Johnson Barr |
December 09, 2020 04:33PM |
|
michael |
December 03, 2020 06:07PM |
|
Ron Keagle |
December 03, 2020 06:52PM |
|
Tenderpaw |
December 04, 2020 08:17AM |
|
dave2-8-0 |
December 04, 2020 08:25AM |
|
Ron Keagle |
December 04, 2020 10:30AM |
|
Olaf Rasmussen |
December 04, 2020 09:33AM |
|
Johnson Barr |
December 09, 2020 04:47PM |
|
Kelly Anderson |
December 04, 2020 09:39AM |