Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Boiler replacement on C's

April 27, 2000 03:32PM
It is my belief that the replacement of boilers on the older 2-8-0s in the teens is an "Urban Legend" among narrow gaugers. Some "expert" was asked about the extended smokeboxes you mentioned and his pontifical answer was that the boilers were replaced. Pigfeathers. New extended smokeboxes with internal spark arrestors were fabricated and riveted on to the original boilers in most cases. In some cases new smokebox extension rings were welded directly to the original short boxes. It would make no logical sense to replace boilers, what with newer locomotives on the property (K-27's) and more planned for the future (K-28's), and the plethora of surplus 2-8-0s that standard gauging and the advent of larger power had caused. You need a few small engines for light branches? Pick the best of the remaining lot and scrap the rest. Why replace boilers on engines that were being phased out? Basically, unless someone comes up with the records showing the purchase of new boilers and the work being performed I have to say the replacement of iron boilers with steel in the teens is a myth.
Subject Author Posted

aesthetics of extended smokeboxes

crh April 27, 2000 12:47PM

Re: aesthetics of extended smokeboxes

Don Richter April 27, 2000 01:46PM

Boiler replacement on C's

Herb Kelsey April 27, 2000 03:32PM

Re: Boiler replacement on C's

Les Clark April 27, 2000 04:30PM

Re: Boiler replacement on C's

Earl April 28, 2000 06:11PM

The 346

Don Richter April 29, 2000 09:11AM

Re: Boiler replacement on C's

Dennis O'Berry May 01, 2000 12:56PM

Re: Boiler replacement on C's

Herb Kelsey May 01, 2000 04:54PM

Re: RGS Boilers

Earl May 01, 2000 07:39PM

Re: RGS Boilers

Herb Kelsey May 02, 2000 03:42PM

Re: RGS Boilers

Dennis O'Berry May 03, 2000 10:01AM

It's 10 o'clock, do you know where your stack is?

Kelly Anderson April 27, 2000 07:26PM

Smokeboxes, The Long and Short of It

Kelly Anderson April 27, 2000 07:12PM

464's smokebox

Marty Knox April 27, 2000 07:41PM

Re: 464's smokebox

Steve Zuiderveen May 03, 2000 06:21PM

speaking of the GW

crh April 28, 2000 11:53AM

Re: speaking of the GW

Phil Johnson April 28, 2000 07:49PM

C-21's and other Baldwin Critters

Mike Trent April 30, 2000 07:59PM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.