Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Brass model Hall of Shame

January 26, 2001 10:30AM
Where do you want to start ? A host of models have been turned out over the years in many scales that were inaccurate and poorly detailed .Some looked nothing like the prototype !I will recount the stars in the Brass Hall of Shame .
Westside models Hon3 K-27s ...25 years ago Westside imported a Vauclain compound K-27 as well as an intermediate (simple valve) version .The boilers were several inches larger than the prototype . The frames as well as several other large parts were poorly coined . They looked awful ! The "modern" versions , however ,were properly proportioned .A friend's wife ,in a rage ,put his Vauclain version ,in box ,under the tires of her car and spun out on it,flattening the model! Looking back ,no big loss...Another was Sunset imported some K-28s in On3 and Sn3 .Their biggest problems were the air tanks were too small and the engines sat too high .These problems were not hard to remedy .
PFM ,trying to open up a market in Sn3 ,imported some terrible RGS tenwheelers years ago .Aside from poor workmanship ,the boilers were too big ,making these models ver odd looking .It was a real challenge to make any of these models run .
Many poor models happended along the time when Korea was gearing up to construct brass models .A host of problems ,mainly cultural and logistical ,plagued early Korea importers .It put many fine importers out of business . I suspect since Asia uses the metric system , and drawings had to be "translated"to metric measurements , this was a source of a lot of model inaccuracies . What fine doorstops do any of you have to add to the Brass Model Hall of Shame ?
Subject Author Posted

K-27? K-28? Boiler? Cab?

SR Bush January 26, 2001 10:05AM

Brass model Hall of Shame

El Coke the brass monkey January 26, 2001 10:30AM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Earl January 26, 2001 12:41PM

Slumsh*t and Custom Trash

El Coke the brassmeister January 26, 2001 07:22PM

Re: Slumsh*t and Custom Trash

Duane Richardson January 27, 2001 12:30PM

Re: Slumsh*t and Custom Trash

Scott Hightower January 27, 2001 02:50PM

Re: Slumsh*t and Custom Trash

John Vandenberg January 27, 2001 03:16PM

Re: Slumsh*t and Custom Trash

Earl January 27, 2001 04:19PM

Re: Earl the Modler?

John Vandenberg January 27, 2001 04:38PM

Re: Earl the Modeler?

Earl January 28, 2001 01:00PM

Re: Slumsh*t and Custom Trash

Steffen Rosmus January 30, 2001 12:32PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Fred January 26, 2001 01:23PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

AL P. January 26, 2001 02:39PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Earl January 26, 2001 03:43PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Al P January 27, 2001 07:28AM

Re: Westside K-28's

Mike Trent January 28, 2001 09:27PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Scott Hightower January 26, 2001 02:47PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Fred January 26, 2001 02:58PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Roger Cutter January 26, 2001 03:12PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Stevo del Applegato January 26, 2001 04:45PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Roger Cutter January 26, 2001 09:59PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Chris Calaway January 26, 2001 11:40PM

High Brass Country

El Coke January 27, 2001 06:50AM

Re: High Brass Country

Roger Cutter January 27, 2001 07:03AM

Re: High Brass Country

RichB January 27, 2001 05:19PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame, odd performance

Hobosteve January 29, 2001 03:20PM

Re:74

Mike Trent January 28, 2001 09:13PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Boris Serena January 27, 2001 02:50AM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Gordon Reynolds January 27, 2001 09:10AM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Steffen Rosmus January 30, 2001 12:37PM

Brass model Hall of Shame, My nomination

Rick Steele January 27, 2001 11:46AM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Dennis O'Berry January 28, 2001 12:42PM

Re: Brass model Hall of Shame

Frank Martindell January 31, 2001 07:56PM

Re: Westside takes the cake

John Vandenberg January 27, 2001 10:22AM

Re: Westside takes the cake

Earl January 27, 2001 11:00AM

More Trash Brass

Stevo del Applegato January 27, 2001 10:41PM

Westside and Gem Models

El Coke January 28, 2001 08:37AM

Re: Westside hall of shame!

Michael Allen January 28, 2001 01:32PM

A real piece of crap

Grant Houston January 28, 2001 05:10PM

Re: A real piece of crap

Steffen Rosmus January 30, 2001 12:36PM

Scratchbuilder's art

El Coke January 28, 2001 05:48PM

Re: Scratchbuilder's art& fixing problems

Fred January 28, 2001 09:55PM

Right, Fred--Besides....

Mike Trent January 29, 2001 07:15AM

Re: Westside takes the cake

Steffen Rosmus January 29, 2001 03:45PM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.