Before we condemn Jerry Day for his viewpoints, perhaps it might be wise to understand what his viewpoint is. As someone who has known Jerry for many years and having followed his off-and-on postings on this forum, I feel that his position on this issue of historical correctness is being misunderstood. What I understand him to always be saying is that being historically correct and accurate will not put fewer paying riders into the seats; and in fact, will likely increase ridership. Passengers will not stay away because No. 9 has a red or a black roof--they could care less. However, being historically correct gives the operation an educational or museum aspect it might not have otherwise. As such, it is more likely to attract the support and patronage of those that are concerned with historical accuracy. I feel certain that Jerry is not interested in shutting down the passenger operation--after all it pays the bills. I think what he is saying and has been saying is that there is no reason we cannot have both--a tourist hauling operation and an authentic museum setting. There is not a downside to being historically correct.
If I have misstated Jerry's views, I am sure that he will let me know. However, do not condemn his viewpoint on this issue because of a perceived insult, real or otherwise. I believe that his opinion on this issue of historical accuracy has merit. Without wanting to insult anyone, I happen to agree with this point of view. I would not be surprised if most of the others on this forum also agree.