Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Re: I wanta be an Engineer for a day.

Wade Hall
August 20, 2000 04:58PM
Personally, I don't think any "engineer or fireman for a day" program is a good idea. Here's why, and I speak from some experience:
A number of years ago (pre-Friends of C&TS), I spent the better part of a week as a student fireman and switchman on the C&TS--just in the yard mind you, no road work. I was picked for this duty partly because I had a fair working knowledge of the General Code of Operating Rules. I was lucky to fire for several very knowledgeable (and patient) engineers. (I have tremendous respect for "good steam hands", and I believe the C&TS, for one, has a number of them.) What I found out was that firing was a very complex job. More importantly, the safety of the locomotive (everything from water level to watching the fireman's side of the train during switching moves) requires constant attention. It's NOT railfanning! After nearly a week of firing in the yard, I was minimally competent as a fireman and I could do one thing essential to survival pretty well: prime and run the injector. As far as firing on the road, well I wasn't ready to try that--that's at a whole 'nother level.
Notice here that I have said nothing about running a locomotive. I would think that a least a couple of weeks of training (and a thorough knowledge of the rules) would be necessary before anyone should be permitted to barely open the throttle on a steam engine. (They're a helluva lot different than a diesel, and I--frankly--wouldn't want an experienced diesel engineer opening the throttle on steam engine without plenty of instruction.)
I don't blame anybody for wanting to run a steam locomotive. But it's not something someone can do with 10 minutes of instruction--and the C&TS (or any other railroad) would be foolish to permit it, in my opinion. Now if someone wants to train as a fireman just like a regular employee would do, and is willing to invest the time to do so, well, maybe that's another story.
Flame away, but we should remember that this is not 12" to the foot model railroading. It's the real thing.
Subject Author Posted

I wanta be an Engineer for a day.

Hoss August 19, 2000 05:40PM

Me. too!!!

Towne Comee August 20, 2000 11:00AM

Re: Me. too!!!

Tom Stewart August 21, 2000 10:28AM

Re: I wanta be an Engineer for a day.

Helge Karkoska August 20, 2000 11:13AM

Re: I wanta be an Engineer for a day.

Wade Hall August 20, 2000 04:58PM

learning curve

El Coke August 20, 2000 09:29PM

Re: learning curve

George Gaskill August 23, 2000 06:36PM

Re: I wanta be an Engineer for a day.

Towne Comee August 21, 2000 05:58AM

Re: I wanta be an Engineer for a day.

c hawkins August 21, 2000 11:17AM

Re: I wanta be an Engineer for a day.

G. W. Laepple August 21, 2000 01:25PM

Re: I wanta be an Engineer for a day.

c hawkins August 21, 2000 02:02PM

Re: Reality.

Michael Allen August 21, 2000 06:35PM

Re: I wanta be an Engineer for a day.

W. Gleckler August 22, 2000 09:40PM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.