Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Outside frame vs Inside frame

June 27, 2016 03:34PM
Other than the issue clamed by WP&Y regarding outside frame engines derailing on the ice, are there any other disadvantages to outside-frame narrow gauge locomotives? I see many advantages, such as a larger, lower boiler for better center of gravity giving potential to more pulling power. But why did the D&RGW favor outside frame locomotives while many other 3' gauge railroads in the USA that bought locomotives after ~1900 stick with inside frames? And if WP&Y had issues with counterweights and ice, wouldn't the D&RGW have the same issue? What are the advantages to having an inside frame? Cheaper? Faster? Easier to work on?

Seems outside frame locomotives were favored by D&RGW, the Mexican and Central American Railroads, and the Arizona Morenci area railroads. White Pass, Sumpter Valley, and EBT all had inside frame 2-8-2s.

Thoughts?
Kevin
Subject Author Posted

Outside frame vs Inside frame

MSRRKevin June 27, 2016 03:34PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

kcsivils June 27, 2016 03:52PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

guymonmd June 28, 2016 01:58PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

Jim Grigsby June 28, 2016 03:15PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

Eugene Blabey June 27, 2016 05:39PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

MSRRKevin June 27, 2016 05:53PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

rehunn June 27, 2016 06:02PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

Stan Fischer June 27, 2016 07:01PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

bcp June 27, 2016 06:56PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

Charlie Mutschler June 27, 2016 07:28PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

Hadder June 28, 2016 08:55AM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

Chris Webster June 28, 2016 09:29AM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

dougvv June 28, 2016 01:26PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

MSRRKevin June 28, 2016 10:18AM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

brian budeit June 28, 2016 02:08PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

dougvv June 28, 2016 07:05PM

Re: Outside frame vs Inside frame

Skip June 30, 2016 12:14AM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login