Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Armchair quarterbacks, it's fun....

July 03, 2011 04:20PM
I'm reading below the interesting conversations regarding restoration of a K-37 and I want to add my two cents worth. I've hung around UP Steam for a number of years and I realize that I still don't really know very much about steam engines, boilers and running gear. Ed Dickens is learning right now, if you'll pardon me for bringing his name up.

However, there is one item that I have learned. You start with money and lots of it, no matter which steam engine you want to restore. After that, you hire a qualified boiler expert to come in and assess how much work it will be, and then add more money to that project.

I am told that Marty Knox is a good resource and if anyone can bring a steam locomotive back from the dead, he'll be the one. C&TS will be wise to keep this connection good for future locomotive assessments. Once 463 is steaming again, maybe it would be money well spent to hire Marty to look over the 490 series and issue a report on which one could be restored. From the outside, you can't tell anything about a boiler's condition. And 497 could have developed some issues in the boiler which might make others more desireable (and less expensive) to restore. We all want a K-37 to steam again because this makes the roster more historically authentic.

Again, there are many who are more qualified than I to comment on this subject. There's a recently retired fella in Cheyenne who has incredible experience with all aspects of railroading. Someone from C&TS should approach him to spend a week in Chama and he could give some good direction for the future.

Jim Burrill
Ft. Collins, Colorado
Subject Author Posted

Armchair quarterbacks, it's fun....

Steam Geek July 03, 2011 04:20PM

Re: Armchair quarterbacks, it's fun....

South Park July 04, 2011 03:05AM

Re: Armchair quarterbacks, it's fun....

Dave Bates July 04, 2011 10:20AM

Thanks Jim,

gothpapa July 04, 2011 08:31AM

Re: Armchair quarterbacks, it's fun....

mikerowe July 04, 2011 11:32AM

mike, i don't think jim was making...

gothpapa July 04, 2011 05:14PM

Re: mike, i don't think jim was making...

mikerowe July 04, 2011 10:58PM

Re: mike, i don't think jim was making...

South Park July 05, 2011 02:03AM

Re: mike, i don't think jim was making...

gothpapa July 05, 2011 10:01AM

Re: mike, i don't think jim was making...

mikerowe July 05, 2011 10:22AM

Re: But ... but ... Armchair Quarterbacking IS fun -

Russo Loco July 07, 2011 11:23PM

Re: But ... but ... Armchair Quarterbacking IS fun -

gothpapa July 08, 2011 08:53AM

Re: But ... But ... Armchair Silverbacking is FUN -

Russo Loco July 08, 2011 03:14PM

Re: But ... But ... Armchair Silverbacking is FUN -

gothpapa July 08, 2011 09:23PM

Re: mike, i don't think jim was making...

South Park July 07, 2011 11:37PM

Re: mike, i don't think jim was making...

Fred Folk July 08, 2011 09:27AM

Re: mike, i don't think jim was making...

gothpapa July 08, 2011 12:19PM

Re: mike, i don't think jim was making...

mikerowe July 08, 2011 12:22PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login