Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

PRSL
April 07, 2006 02:46PM
If you notice my few distracters are the ones spouting the venom? I only supplied a book review, which gave counts of what one is to expect if they bought the book. What your beef, I recommended that one should buy it? I don’t like the kind of book reviews in most fan magazines that just give the content list and never any opinion of how well it was done in fear they might disfavor someone. One can only tell by the pattern of the publisher what to expect. I told it like it was. There is Not one map in the book to aid anyone to see where the tracks laid in the land.
I wonder about the full story why the valuation maps were not shared. He must have been a smart judge of people. The valuation maps are at the NA, College Park, MD and I know Gary was given a budget to go there to get them but it was not done. Also, the State Park office at Blain gives out a free map with a photo of Climax #265 (a photo which could have been use) of the public trails built on the grades of the Perry Lumber Co. and the Path Valley uncompleted RR grade. It could have been incorporated as part of the story.
Chester: When you copy a history written by Bill Gove from a copyrighted magazine called the Northern Logger and put it on the internet you are in violation of copyright law and you are stealing someone else work. My “threat” was informing you of that stupid action. I don’t think most of the readers of the discussion site would disagree.
A book review is a book review and the ones who get the book can compare the over 50 duplicated photos and see what they think of the quality, if that is what you don’t like about my review. Besides it is sold out so what is your big fuss? Vent on and see if I care.
Subject Author Posted

BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALLEY

PRSL February 19, 2006 08:28PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

G. W. Laepple February 19, 2006 09:03PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

PRSL February 19, 2006 10:09PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

G. W. Laepple February 20, 2006 06:19AM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Jim Weinschenker April 06, 2006 10:26AM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Chester Louis April 06, 2006 12:50PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Donald Foster April 06, 2006 02:50PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Douglas vV April 06, 2006 02:56PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Jim Weinschenker April 06, 2006 03:13PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Eugene H. Blabey April 06, 2006 06:22PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Jim Weinschenker April 06, 2006 06:40PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

PRSL April 07, 2006 08:07AM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Chester Louis April 07, 2006 09:30AM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

G. W. Laepple April 07, 2006 09:59AM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

John Craft April 07, 2006 10:21AM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Ed Stabler April 07, 2006 11:03AM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

PRSL April 08, 2006 06:49AM

AMEN *NM*

Douglas vV April 07, 2006 08:56PM

Time out - or not...

Don Richter April 08, 2006 09:40AM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Burr Hubbell April 07, 2006 11:27AM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

PRSL April 07, 2006 02:46PM

Re: BOOK REVIEW- EASTERN NG FANS, RE: SHERMAN VALL

Jim Weinschenker April 08, 2006 09:08AM

GO JIM!!! *NM*

Donald Foster April 08, 2006 02:30PM

Now you have gone too far!!

Chester Louis April 13, 2006 06:23AM

Re: Now you have gone too far!!

Les Clark April 13, 2006 05:47PM

Re: Now you have gone too far!!

Carl April 13, 2006 05:57PM

Re: Now you have gone too far!!

El Hell April 13, 2006 06:50PM

Can we please close this thread? Thanx. *NM*

Don Richter April 14, 2006 08:42AM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.