Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

August 15, 2004 03:12PM
I have quite a number of Beebe & Clegg books in my library. I consider them very entertaining and readable books, but you had better check out any facts presented. One night, years ago, I sat down with B&C's "Rio Grande-Mainline of the Rockies" and started writing down all of the factual errors I could find. My list of errors came to five pages. for example:
on page 50 they state that the" Lobato trestle is the highest bridge on the Alamosa-Durango run." This is incorrect, as the Lobato trestle is 100' high and the Cascade Cr. trestle is 137' high.
on page 250 they state that the rails of the Moffat Road reached Craig, Colorado in 1911. This is also incorrect, as the rails actually reached Craig in November of 1913.
one more example: on page 23, under the photo of men on a hand car, B&C state that the scene was taken at Colton, Utah "in the construction of the original line of the Pleasant Valley RR, soon to become an element in the ever-growing Rio Grande Western". However, the Utah & Pleasant Valley RR did not pass through Colton, Utah-so either the picture is not at Colton or the Railroad is not the Utah & Pleasant Valley.
I have quite a few more of these factual errors from just the "Mainline of the Rockies" book alone. I have spotted errors in other B&C books as well; so read em' and enjoy em', but check out the facts.
Dick
Subject Author Posted

Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Gregory Raven August 15, 2004 10:02AM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

John Sporseen August 15, 2004 10:41AM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

South Park August 15, 2004 11:38AM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Dave Peterson August 15, 2004 11:58AM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Dick August 15, 2004 03:12PM

Poor history.....BUT

John West August 15, 2004 03:58PM

Re: Poor history.....BUT

Charlie Mutschler August 15, 2004 07:14PM

Re: Poor history.....BUT

Gregory Raven August 15, 2004 08:20PM

Re: Poor history.....BUT

South Park August 16, 2004 07:58AM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Brian Norden August 15, 2004 11:18PM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Lon Wall August 16, 2004 08:41PM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Bill Adkins August 17, 2004 04:42PM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Lon Wall August 17, 2004 04:51PM

Hear , Hear !

El Coke August 17, 2004 10:58PM

Re: Hear , Hear Again!

Craig Kumler August 18, 2004 10:42AM

Beebe & Clegg

Dick Seelye August 18, 2004 03:03PM

Re: Beebe & Clegg

Tom Peterman August 25, 2004 08:40AM

Old Chinese sayings about the arts...

El Coke August 18, 2004 03:32PM

Re: Old Chinese sayings about the arts...

Wooly August 18, 2004 04:45PM

Online novel publishing

El Coke August 18, 2004 05:20PM

print on demand publishing

Douglas vV August 18, 2004 06:30PM

Private publishing.

El Coke August 19, 2004 10:47AM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Ron Rosenquist August 18, 2004 05:12PM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Lon Wall August 18, 2004 11:44PM

Re: Beebe, Clegg and History ???

Tom U. Leaton August 24, 2004 06:13PM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.