It all depends on how well it is done. I have seen some well done dubbed audio and some that is revolting. As an old head who did a lot of audio recording, I can pretty much hear what was going on in my head. There was a great video done on the RGS years ago that featured audio dubbed from the D&S and C&TS. Some believable, most was not. I recall some shots of RGS 42 drifting down through Lost Canyon accompanied by the sound of D&S 481, with a big 6-chime ATSF whistle bombing up Hermosa Hill. Ghastly. I hit the mute button for the rest of the show.
When all else fails nice easy background music with short, informative narration works just fine.....
Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 08/27/2019 01:12PM by Earl.