Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

March 25, 2001 04:04PM
HKA,
You're right, however, superpower could be produced, also, the technology is the same, just bigger.
As for the single piece cast frames, I would go for a solid fabricated one any day. Castings have the annoying tendancy to crack right in the most expensive places.
With the CNC mills and other computerized stuff, flame cutters, plasma cutters, water cutters, tolerances could be maintained that would give a frame as rigid as cast, but without all of the finish work.
As for weight, how about some of those spent uranium shells that the government has so many of? They're heavier than lead. (Joke)
I would go for all roller bearing surfaces if it was my money. Why? Lower friction coefficient and lower maintenance costs.
I can personally attest to the durability and strength of roller bearings on freight cars. We don't have anywhere near the hotboxes that we used to with friction bearings. The boys on the NS Steam Crew used to swear by them. If you've ever used brass or babbett bearings for any length of time, during the initial break-in period, you do more swearing at them.
On the UP engines, only the axles are roller bearing, the rods are brass bearings. We swore at them a lot, too.
If I were going to build a steam locomotive today, I would employ the most modern metallurgy and technology available, bar none. After all, you are talking about a product where people are putting their lives on the line, but one to also make a profit for the owners.
Simple, Dependable and low maintenance would be the ultimate ticket.
Rick Steele
Subject Author Posted

How much $ for a new locomotive ??

El Coke March 23, 2001 01:52PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Glenn Christensen March 23, 2001 02:37PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

pmcassell March 23, 2001 02:49PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Glenn Christensen March 23, 2001 03:44PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Kelly Anderson March 23, 2001 05:20PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Rick Steele March 24, 2001 08:16AM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Dennis O'Berry March 24, 2001 11:25AM

durago parlor car

dan hargrove March 26, 2001 05:34PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Kelly Anderson March 25, 2001 06:48AM

Boiler design and cost.

Rick Steele March 25, 2001 03:43PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Michael Allen March 23, 2001 05:23PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

James C Patten March 23, 2001 05:58PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Glenn Christensen March 23, 2001 09:34PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Lukas Rosenthaler March 23, 2001 07:57PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Bruce R. Pier March 23, 2001 08:46PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Tim Smith March 23, 2001 11:49PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Hugh Odom March 24, 2001 04:47AM

Locomotive cost ,comparison and different approach

Dan Markoff March 24, 2001 05:59AM

Was it a good quote ?

El Coke March 24, 2001 06:10AM

Re: Was it a good quote ?

Dan Markoff March 24, 2001 06:49AM

Superior Boiler Company

Steve Peck March 24, 2001 07:13AM

Re: Locomotive cost ,comparison and different appr

pmc March 24, 2001 08:53AM

Re: Locomotive cost ,comparison and different appr

Mik March 25, 2001 12:24AM

People!

Herb Kelsey March 26, 2001 05:58PM

Re: People!

Mikky March 26, 2001 06:35PM

Re: Locomotive cost ,comparison and different appr

Curtis F. March 24, 2001 09:06PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Rick Steele March 24, 2001 08:40AM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Les Clark March 24, 2001 03:49PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Rick Steele March 24, 2001 06:00PM

I resemble that remark...

El Coke March 24, 2001 09:18PM

Me, too

Rick Steele March 25, 2001 03:48PM

You always were an optimist, Rick *NM*

Herb Kelsey March 26, 2001 06:12PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

pmc March 25, 2001 09:24AM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Mik March 25, 2001 05:36PM

Depends on how authentic you want it.

Curtis F. March 24, 2001 08:45PM

Re: Depends on how authentic you want it.

Boris Serena March 25, 2001 12:46AM

New Steamer: Can Do

PMC March 25, 2001 09:44AM

Me, Authentic???

Rick Steele March 25, 2001 03:37PM

Re: Me, Authentic??? Not you.

Curtis F. March 25, 2001 05:09PM

Save it here or save it there

Mik March 25, 2001 05:55PM

Re: Save it here or save it there

PMC March 26, 2001 06:38AM

Economies

Rick Steele March 26, 2001 08:56AM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

HKA March 25, 2001 09:41AM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Rick Steele March 25, 2001 04:04PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

HKA March 25, 2001 09:09PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Rick Steele March 26, 2001 09:12AM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Mik March 26, 2001 05:23PM

I can see it now

Fred T March 28, 2001 02:08PM

Now Now Fred

Kevin Cook March 28, 2001 02:19PM

So can I

Rick Steele March 28, 2001 03:48PM

Re: So can I

Fred T March 28, 2001 09:35PM

Re: So can I

Rick Steele March 29, 2001 07:30AM

Would Super-K need ribbon rail

Tom Stewart March 29, 2001 12:12PM

Re: Would Super-K need ribbon rail

Mik March 30, 2001 11:47AM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Curtis F. March 25, 2001 05:15PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Paul D March 26, 2001 02:52PM

Re: Why operate an artifact ?

Rick Renz March 26, 2001 03:54PM

Replicas

El Coke March 26, 2001 10:00PM

Re: Replicas

Glenn Christensen March 27, 2001 04:56PM

Re: How much $ for a new locomotive ??

Earl Pitts March 27, 2001 05:38PM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.