Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

December 13, 2012 02:05AM
I didn't want to hijack the WW&F thread on rebuilding the #9, but the rebuild of that locomotive brings up an interesting question concerning the ability to build a replica of a South Park Mason Bogie. Here is a quote from that thread;

Quote
WW&F #9
The discussion on the WW&F Museum forums sheds considerable light on something that may not be obvious to casual observers who haven't visited the operation in Alna, ME. The rebuild on Number 9 is not simply a rebuild to "as-built" condition, due to some disconcerting flaws in the original design. I believe that the stress on the draw-bar was effectively being transferred to the boiler, because the connection between the fore and aft sections of the frame WAS the boiler. Obviously, in today's environment, that wouldn't be considered a particularly good idea. As a result, the folks at the WW&F have had to do some re-engineering of the original frame, to physically connect the two sections of the frame, and have the resulting structure support the boiler vs. incorporating the boiler.

If putting this stress through the boiler is not allowed by today's standards, then it looks like a replica Mason Bogie would not be allowed to be built; or steamed up anyways. Is this true?
Subject Author Posted

Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Kevin K December 13, 2012 02:05AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Bernie Perch December 13, 2012 04:54AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Bernie Perch December 13, 2012 09:42AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Linn W. Moedinger December 13, 2012 05:01AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

South Park December 13, 2012 07:58AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Kevin K December 13, 2012 10:57AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Charlie Mutschler December 14, 2012 08:01AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Jeff Ramsey December 13, 2012 08:26AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Kevin K December 13, 2012 11:02AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

GeorgeGaskill December 13, 2012 02:06PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

weston1879 December 13, 2012 03:01PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

weston1879 December 13, 2012 03:07PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

weston1879 December 13, 2012 03:30PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed? Attachments

mikerowe December 13, 2012 05:35PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed? Attachments

Jeff Ramsey December 13, 2012 06:36PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

South Park December 14, 2012 09:58AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

weston1879 December 14, 2012 10:28AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

mikerowe December 14, 2012 06:10PM

Re: Would a Masonic-Boogeyman even BE Allowed ... confused smiley

Russo Loco December 14, 2012 02:35PM

Re: Wood a Mason-Garratt Even BEE Aloud ... confused smiley

mikerowe December 14, 2012 06:15PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed? Attachments

Tim Bain December 13, 2012 07:13PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

weston1879 December 13, 2012 08:46PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Jeff Ramsey December 14, 2012 05:06AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed? Attachments

Todd Hackett December 13, 2012 09:17PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

GeorgeGaskill December 14, 2012 03:12PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Kelly Anderson December 13, 2012 11:21AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Jerry Huck December 13, 2012 09:30PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

weston1879 December 14, 2012 12:04AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

South Park December 14, 2012 10:04AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

David Johnson December 14, 2012 09:22PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

jim pallow December 13, 2012 12:49PM

Re: Mason Bogie to Howardsville?

Jerry Huck December 13, 2012 05:49PM

Re: Mason-Garratt t' H'ardsville? ... thumbs upthumbs up

Russo Loco December 14, 2012 11:09PM

Re: Mason-Garratt t' H'ardsville? ... thumbs upthumbs up

South Park December 15, 2012 01:16AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Randall Hess December 13, 2012 08:50PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Rob Gardner December 13, 2012 11:51PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

weston1879 December 14, 2012 08:16AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Rob Gardner December 15, 2012 03:23PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

weston1879 December 15, 2012 05:21PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Rick Steele December 15, 2012 07:19PM

Re: Would a Mason Bogie be Allowed? - Yes It Is!!

Randall Hess December 16, 2012 06:31PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

jfengineer December 15, 2012 01:56PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Jeff Ramsey December 16, 2012 06:50PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

South Park December 16, 2012 10:53PM

YES!!! A Replica Mason Bogie Could Be Allowed!!!

Randall Hess December 17, 2012 06:01PM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

South Park December 18, 2012 09:24PM

Re: Would a Mustacheo'd Slide-Rule Wizard Even BE Allowed?

Russo Loco December 21, 2012 09:52PM

Re: Would a Mustacheo'd Slide-Rule Wizard Even BE Allowed?

Jeff Ramsey December 22, 2012 12:22AM

Re: Would a Mustacheo'd Slide-Rule Wizard Even BE Allowed?

South Park December 23, 2012 08:32AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

El Skonk December 22, 2012 08:59AM

The one that got away

weston1879 December 22, 2012 10:30AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

South Park December 23, 2012 08:35AM

Re: Would a Replica Mason Bogie Even Allowed?

Gavin Hamilton December 23, 2012 02:26PM

Re: Mason Bogie 2-6-0-6T vs Fairlie 0-4-4T ... confused smiley

Russo Loco December 23, 2012 06:40PM

Re: Mason Bogie 2-6-0-6T vs Fairlie 0-4-4T ... confused smiley

Gavin Hamilton December 24, 2012 12:50AM

Re: Mason Bogies, Fairlies, Meyers, Garratts, etc

Brian Norden December 24, 2012 09:53AM

Re: Mason Bogies, Fairlies, Meyers, Garratts, etc

Gavin Hamilton December 26, 2012 10:58AM

Re: Mason Bogies, Fairlies, Meyers, Garratts, etc

christensenge December 26, 2012 04:48PM

deleted --redundant.

gbrewer December 26, 2012 06:28PM

Re: Mason Bogies, Fairlies, Meyers, Garratts, etc

gbrewer December 26, 2012 06:29PM

Re: Mason Bogies, Fairlies, Meyers, Garratts, etc

Russo Loco December 26, 2012 08:53PM



Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.

Click here to login