Fred,
I agree. The original post was talking down the NPC 4-4-0 Cab-Forward. I have to admitt I like that little thing. I guess it comes from growing up here in California.
I have not much use for the N&S "Y" Class. Bu Tugly (Butt Ugly) But I am sure there are many who just love them. It's all in the eye of the beholder.
Kevin