I ask the question based on the latest from the recent TRAIN convention meeting: "The association board, meeting in Milwaukee for its annual convention, passed a resolution Sunday asking members to follow Federal Railroad Administration regulations about cab riders. That means not allowing anyone in the cab of an operating locomotive except for 'authorized personnel.'"
Granted, cab rides are a potential hazard -- no doubt about it. Even operating a steam locomotive in the 21st century is a big risk. After all, diesel locomotives can provide the same transportation with less cost and less danger. The White Pass certainly has proven that it works even for a tourist line.
It is just that there are a relative few of us who don’t want to see steam die. We want to see it continue for years to come. Steam in the 21st century is not necessary, it is a hobby really, and while it can be deadly serious, it is supposed to be for fun.
I am very doubtful that the young enthusiasts are stepping up in sufficient numbers to replace us older ones. Sure, there will always be a few attracted to steam, especially based on their own experience, if any, with it. I do think that the numbers are dwindling as old timers like me die off and new, potential enthusiasts are discouraged. Making the cab off-limit to all but the anointed will do nothing to perpetuate the love of steam.