Welcome! Log In Create A New Profile

Advanced

American Beauty????

April 22, 2000 09:18PM
Here’s a question just for fun. In your own opinion, which was/is the best looking narrow gauge locomotive to run in Colorado (sorry EBT, SVR, WP&Y ect. We’ll get to you later).
I though this was going to be an easy question for myself until I started thinking about it. The lines on a K-28 are nice with the tall stacks, but so is the K-27. However mudhens have those short tenders. Then how about C&S #9, had to find anything wrong with her but then I like Ridgway spark arresters (on C&S engines, not K-36's) Then again, the DSP&P Masons were Good looking with the big stacks.
How about the Ury and their 2-6-6-2s……great engines but not much to look at (if you disagree Lets hear it). One nice looking engine was the D&RGW 315 in the 1940’s but I think she looked great back when she was a Florence & Cripple Creek engine.
RGS #42 in the 1940’s?… nice, but the RGS’s #74 was easy on the eyes to, no…..wait…..I did say I liked those ridgway stack caps…..so then….that means the 74 was prettier as a C&S engine; I think?
Then, there is the Eureka….hard to beat her. Maybe a T-12 back in the 1920’s? How about D&RGW’s little diesel #50?……NEXT!!!……RGS Goose #4, sure, if you like the bus body; but if you like the older style then it would have to be #7, but then again, did she look better when she had a black paint job…………….........This is not as easy as I thought it was going to be.
Wait……..I GOT IT……of course…… the best looking narrow gauge engine ever to run in Colorado must be Rio Grande Southern’s all time favorite, the 4-6-0 #20. …..Yup, that’s it for me. No other engine was so pleasing to the eye and photogenic, as she was, and is today…….BUT….….now that I think of it….. #20 had an even better looking sister. The RGS’s #25.
NOW, I got it…..It must be #25. All the looks of the 20 but with a bigger head light, straight Hand rail, and a perfect size tender with the flared top (after 25 was scraped, this same tender went behind #20 and made her look better as well). Number 25…in my opinion, Beautiful.
But, then again…………………………………………..
When you work a 12 hour grave yard shift waiting for a phone call from EMS, you have time to Think about this kind of stuff. (I know it shows).
So what do you think, and why?????
Just for fun, Tim Bain
Subject Author Posted

American Beauty????

Tim Bain April 22, 2000 09:18PM

Re: American Beauty????

John West April 23, 2000 12:04AM

Re: American Beauty????

Herb Kelsey April 23, 2000 01:04AM

But my real choice....

Herb Kelsey April 23, 2000 01:05AM

Re: American Beauty????

Tim Bain April 24, 2000 02:46AM

Re: American Beauty????

Herb Kelsey April 24, 2000 07:52AM

What Wreck?

T.E. Scott Jr April 25, 2000 11:25AM

Re: What Wreck?

Herb Kelsey April 25, 2000 07:19PM

Re: What Wreck?

T.E. Scott Jr. April 26, 2000 07:28AM

Re: What Wreck?

Herb Kelsey April 26, 2000 04:40PM

479, with snowplow

Mike Trent April 23, 2000 07:02AM

Re: American Beauty????

John Hammond April 23, 2000 11:44AM

Re: American Beauty????

josh levine April 23, 2000 12:47PM

476, or 375

Josh McNeal April 23, 2000 06:38PM

Re: American Beauty????

C H Moore SR, April 23, 2000 07:10PM

Re: American Beauty????

Charlie Mutschler April 23, 2000 09:08PM



Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.