Somebody settle this argument by running out there and shooting a few stills. A train would even be better or even a speeder.
Looking at the still all the hillside in the distance is reflected, as well as the little pine and the aspen in the distance, and they are all pretty far away----further than the train is from the pond where its right below the train at its closest point. I still think it would be reflected. Ever see John Crafts shot here in May 1993 of the Friends train that followed the Rotary. I used it on my video cover of one of my videos. Perfectly reflects all of the engine and couple of cars rounding the curve.
Nothing finer than a good reflection shot in cool weather with sunshine.
Greg